By: David Schultz
It’s an axiom that Robert Plant will probably understand very soon: there is nothing more dependable (or lucrative) than a classic rock reunion tour. Doubt it? Just recall the intensely piqued collective curiosity that greeted the mere possibility of
Peter Gabriel rejoining his mates in
Genesis for one more trip around the globe. By claiming no tour will follow Led Zeppelin’s November 26th gig in London, Plant threatens to emulate his fellow Brit, who resisted the near-irresistible siren song of a Genesis reunion tour.
Desirable as it may have been, Genesis’ unique history rendered the participation of its original lead singer an expendable luxury. While older fans fondly associate Genesis with Gabriel, many more remember them as Phil Collins’ band. Under Collins’ watch, Genesis gradually evolved from artistic prog-rockers prone to twenty-minute suites into a slick Eighties hit-making machine. Depending on your age and musical inclination, your conception of Genesis will be intimately tied to whether lambs lying down on Broadway or lands of confusion first drew you to the band.
The decision to move Phil Collins from the drums to the microphone in the wake of Gabriel’s 1975 departure did more than simply preserve the band’s chemistry. By staying within the family, so to speak, Genesis not only maintained a sense of continuity, they managed to remain vital and relevant even with Collins’ wildly successful solo career drawing just as much if not more attention. Collins and founding members Mike Rutherford and Tony Banks, preside over the reunited band. Keeping the ties strong, guitarist/bassist Daryl Stuermer and drummer Chester Thompson, long time members of Genesis’ touring band, have also returned to the fold. As Collins, Rutherford and Banks presided over Genesis’ most commercially prolific period, even those who feel that Genesis ceased to exist when Gabriel left will be forced to concede that unlike the
Morrison-less version of The Doors, Mercury-free Queen or even Journey sans Steve Perry, this year’s
Turn It On Again reunion tour carries with it the air of legitimacy. With the summer concert season in its final throes, Genesis returned to the Tri-State area for the first time in more than a decade for a sold-out night at Madison Square Garden and a stadium spectacle two days later at nearby Giants Stadium.
Genesis has always nurtured a visual component, an essential component to any English-bred, art-school refined, progressive rock band of the Seventies.

With Peter Gabriel fronting the band, Genesis turned their concerts into minor spectacles. It’s no surprise that Gabriel became one of MTV’s first stars: his penchant for dressing like a flower and donning costumes predating and presaging the video age that would expand his popularity beyond the art-rock minded. Collins would also find his niche with the MTV generation, fostering a stage personality that perfectly suited the slick but superficial 80s pop culture. Collins would not only find stardom on signature shows like
Miami Vice, as Genesis’ lead singer, his presence helped get the band into heavy rotation on MTV in the days when the network was known for presenting videos.
For their Giants Stadium show, Genesis’
set list touched on all stages of their career including intricate, tempo-shifting conceptual pieces, synth-heavy instrumental numbers, Eighties-era pop classics and lush, syrupy love songs. The immensity of Giants Stadium made a fine venue for Genesis’ broader visual and auditory adventures, although it swallowed many of their subtle nuances. Unless the cameras happened to be projecting a close-up of Collins on the video screens that abutted the stage, his expressive facial features went unnoticed by all but the first few rows. Rather than focus on smaller scales, the evening’s best moments occurred when Collins moved behind the drums and the music filled the spacious grounds.

Even though songs like “Land Of Confusion” and “Invisible Touch” sound like relics from the Eighties, the songs from
Invisible Touch, their touchstone album from that era, received the warmest and most enthusiastic reception. More interesting though was the older Gabriel-era material, if for no other reason because there’s more going on within the songs. Where the latter-era material left Banks with little to do, “In The Cage,” the evening’s best song, had him moving between keyboards and contained everything that made Genesis a formidable and intriguing outfit. Although Mike Rutherford busted out the prog-rock 12 string guitar for older offerings like “Firth of Fifth” and “I Know What I Like,” the night’s most interesting guitar work was turned in by Stuermer, who impressively tackled Steve Hackett’s guitar solos.
Collins proved he is still the ultimate showman, exuding every bit of the quirky charm that made him one of the biggest stars of the late Eighties. A true performer, Collins manages to entertain with
nothing more than a tambourine and his skull. As he did when he joined the band, Collins started the evening on the drums, teaming with Thompson to provide a barrage of percussion to the majestic “Behind The Lines” before moving to center stage for an apt run through “Turn It On Again.” Pulling double duty, Collins would periodically set down the microphone and return to the drums for extended periods. Showing he hasn’t lost his touch, his purported drum “duel” with Thompson wasn’t as much of a battle as it was two expert drummers working together to create a series of intriguing, interlocking rhythms.
Given an extra boost by extended instrumental breaks, “Home By The Sea,” “Mama” and good portions of “Domino” built to notable crescendos and showed how well Collins’ innate sense of melody could be worked into Genesis’ prog-rock model. However, their ventures into pure pop fluffery never entirely clicked and their renditions of “Hold On My Heart” and “Ripples,” were exceptionally boring. Misfires like “Illegal Alien” were thankfully absent from the set list, although the reprehensible “I Can’t Dance” found its way into the encore; Rutherford’s simple yet effective guitar riff unable to rescue the insipid song.
As they have on many of their shows this tour, they closed the night with a perfunctory run through “The Carpet Crawlers.” With eyes closed, Collins gave an emotive reading of one of the band’s greatest musical efforts. In doing so, Collins was fortunate to have missed the distressing sight of many in attendance choosing that moment to head to the parking lot to beat traffic. Maybe it was disrespectful. Then again, maybe they just needed to get home and rest up for the David Lee Roth led version of Van Halen that (
is getting rave reviews) will be coming to town next month.